Alaska’s Death Panels?

The Alaska Legislature passed the Alaska Health Care Decisions Act in 2004, and it was subsequently signed into law by then-Governor Frank Murkowski. It outlined protocols relating to do not resuscitate (DNR) orders to be developed by the State Department of Health and Social Services and implemented by health care providers.

 At the time, pro-life law makers were concerned that the language of the bill could lead to outcomes that came dangerously close to legalizing the termination of human life. So Senator Fred Dyson, Chair of the Senate Committee on Health and Social Services, along with Lt. Governor Loren Leman and the American Catholic Conference, worked to amend the legislation by inserting language that ostensibly protected the right of a patient to make his, or her, own decisions relating to end of life issues, offering a presumption of life in the absence of a directive, and making it abundantly clear that the law did not authorize any form of “mercy killing,” “euthanasia,” or “assisted suicide.”

Notwithstanding that, some health care providers in the State of Alaska are abusing terminally ill patients and denying care based on a presumption of statutory authority for a doctor to unilaterally place DNR orders on patients against their own will, and that of their families. Backed by the expertise of so-called “ethics committees” acting as death panels, these institutions have empowered doctors in their employ to play God, and apparently there is no recourse. The Alaska Health Care Decisions Act offers immunity to health care providers against charges of assisted suicide, or homicide, in such cases.

I spent two hours yesterday afternoon with a family member whose loved one was unilaterally designated DNR by a doctor at Providence Hospital with the full blessing of the institution’s “ethicist.” Because the family refused to sign a statement of assent, the hospital subsequently denied them care. AS 13.52.065 was cited as the legal authority for the hospital’s “right to allocate its resources as it will.”

While I am a pro-life Alaskan who believes that life is the supreme value and is its own quality, those who are pro-choice should be no less outraged that patients and their legal powers of attorney are being denied the right to make their own health care choices. It is an outrage that Alaskans would be subjected to death panels masquerading under the guise of a false ethic of compassion. Warning – Alaska’s DNR program operates under the innocuous title of Comfort One.

I would like to believe that what we are dealing with is a rogue institution wrongly interpreting the statute, but my research leads me to believe otherwise. Unfortunately, the language relating to the patient’s right is tucked away in a section of the law dealing with the patient’s capacity to make decisions, setting the bar high, and failing to address powers of attorney. At the same time, it specifically authorizes a physician with charge of a patient to unilaterally place a DNR order, specifying that it is irrevocable unless revoked by a physician.

Attorney Kenneth Kirk, writing in the Alaska Law Review, concluded that “the Alaska Health Care Decisions Act purports to be based on the right to self-determination, combined with a concern for the sanctity of life. Instead, it has been infused with enough loopholes such that doctors and surrogates can terminate lives, even of the unwilling, based on their own philosophical convictions.” Kirk went on to suggest that the law does not comport with the legislature’s philosophical intent.

In light of the foregoing, join me in calling on Governor Parnell to offer immediate redress to this family in need by expediting an Executive Order to close loopholes in the law and protect the most vulnerable among us.

Be Sociable, Share!

5 Comments

  1. avatar
    Mauris non lacinia justo. Donec. says:

    In tristique congue odio sed malesuada. Ut et vestibulum orci. Nam eget lectus augue. Curabitur vulputate mi ac odio mollis a varius risus porttitor. Donec ac quam felis, eget viverra orci. Nullam pellentesque odio nec arcu scelerisque condimentum. Etiam fermentum elit justo, vel tincidunt libero. Nulla quis arcu felis, condimentum ullamcorper enim. Pellentesque commodo condimentum eleifend. Nam at nisi a nulla fringilla suscipit.

    Mauris justo massa, rhoncus semper bibendum nec, interdum et lectus. Pellentesque ultrices ipsum nulla, in cursus sem. Nulla nec felis turpis, sit amet pellentesque augue. Quisque at ipsum ornare diam cursus scelerisque. Suspendisse tincidunt lacus id odio varius lacinia. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Proin felis tortor, bibendum in condimentum sed, aliquet a sem. Nullam sagittis, lectus non placerat placerat, lorem diam ultrices felis, tempor ullamcorper velit erat fringilla purus. Mauris molestie, diam eu mattis ornare, ipsum libero imperdiet erat, vitae semper metus justo bibendum sapien.

    Nunc posuere mattis velit, a faucibus sem facilisis vitae. Ut viverra hendrerit cursus. Curabitur id erat dolor. Nunc vitae elit nec ante venenatis rutrum et et dui. Integer iaculis, justo vitae pulvinar pretium, massa quam aliquam dui, vitae malesuada mi tortor non diam. Nullam ut dolor ligula, ut eleifend dolor. Ut posuere, nulla ut consequat dapibus, ante metus imperdiet sem, eu cursus dui dui posuere leo. Mauris vel velit eget risus sodales varius at ut ligula. Nullam viverra, eros nec scelerisque dapibus, mi erat rutrum sapien, a luctus lectus libero sed lorem. Duis varius dolor vel urna iaculis eget eleifend eros rutrum. Donec massa odio, placerat eu tincidunt vel, rutrum et nulla. Nulla vitae risus suscipit tortor dictum adipiscing. Suspendisse vitae nibh dui, in adipiscing diam. Cras sed eros mi. Donec rutrum auctor arcu, vitae venenatis lectus auctor eu. In a felis mauris, non iaculis libero.

    Donec in eros nec massa convallis auctor at sed purus. Maecenas malesuada, libero id molestie viverra, dolor mauris viverra diam, lobortis ornare nibh lorem in quam. Maecenas sagittis mattis gravida. Phasellus pharetra elit ac justo viverra pharetra. Maecenas pulvinar, lectus eget vestibulum commodo, neque turpis venenatis eros, vitae dapibus felis justo eu lectus. Etiam a diam venenatis tellus tempus venenatis sed non tellus. In quis suscipit quam. Suspendisse ut arcu nec est lobortis consectetur a ut urna. Vestibulum cursus ultricies nulla vel mollis. Fusce et odio risus. Sed fermentum pretium elit, in dignissim nisl tincidunt vel. Fusce tellus leo, viverra ac pulvinar in, gravida a lacus. Pellentesque feugiat dui vel mi hendrerit in venenatis ligula feugiat. Morbi vestibulum tortor non odio lacinia ut dignissim odio fringilla. Etiam in lacus dui. Cras vitae risus tortor.

  2. avatar
    Suspendisse sodales adipiscing nulla, nec. says:

    Cras sit amet mi nibh. Morbi in ipsum nunc, ut bibendum sapien. Ut posuere eleifend sapien, ut imperdiet purus lacinia sed. Donec elementum lectus ac magna rhoncus vitae convallis arcu tempor. Nulla facilisi. Proin consequat nulla a neque mattis dignissim. Cras vestibulum, arcu sit amet tincidunt vestibulum, nulla mi semper est, sit amet imperdiet magna enim bibendum arcu.

    Cum sociis natoque penatibus et magnis dis parturient montes, nascetur ridiculus mus. Curabitur vitae sapien velit, at hendrerit dolor. Phasellus fermentum justo nec diam elementum laoreet faucibus risus auctor. Morbi vitae volutpat sapien. Cras iaculis, lacus pellentesque venenatis tempor, ligula dolor dictum lorem, hendrerit pellentesque purus eros sit amet tortor. Duis sagittis ornare dui, vel dictum leo placerat ut. Integer eros turpis, tristique et feugiat sit amet, pretium nec odio. Aliquam venenatis tempor rutrum. Quisque placerat porta nibh quis pellentesque. Ut et erat vel est faucibus tincidunt.

  3. avatar
    Mauris eros est, commodo eu. says:

    Curabitur lectus neque, dapibus et eleifend non, elementum ut orci. Maecenas congue sapien a diam tempor vitae tincidunt nibh scelerisque. Pellentesque habitant morbi tristique senectus et netus et malesuada fames ac turpis egestas. Donec id sem magna, et adipiscing nibh. Sed vitae eleifend lorem. Donec ullamcorper congue libero, non eleifend augue posuere sed. Cras porta lacus vel quam eleifend hendrerit. Quisque scelerisque orci a turpis molestie in adipiscing nisi fermentum. Cras bibendum sem non velit blandit id egestas ligula commodo. Pellentesque consectetur enim non felis consectetur ut dictum leo luctus.

    Praesent felis tortor, mattis porta pulvinar non, vulputate at lectus. Suspendisse molestie aliquet nulla, ut fermentum ante porta id. Curabitur sed nulla ut urna condimentum aliquam. Vivamus imperdiet laoreet faucibus. Aliquam in augue iaculis lectus varius rhoncus. Nam gravida pulvinar tortor quis porttitor. Morbi tincidunt turpis et neque consectetur mattis. Nulla dui neque, blandit ac pellentesque a, commodo eu justo. Nullam orci tellus, elementum at cursus nec, accumsan ut turpis.

    Donec velit libero, blandit id pharetra quis, varius sit amet nibh. Vivamus tortor erat, tempor non bibendum et, faucibus imperdiet justo. Sed erat nibh, aliquet nec eleifend eget, fringilla eget sem. Integer et risus velit, sed egestas sem. Morbi risus nibh, lobortis eget feugiat quis, ornare in elit. Ut dapibus eleifend urna sed venenatis. Nunc condimentum, sem non convallis faucibus, diam lacus vestibulum turpis, eget tempus nisi est blandit lectus. Sed consequat sagittis bibendum. Ut quis augue lacus, mollis dignissim elit.

    Aenean sed sollicitudin nunc. Duis est neque, rhoncus condimentum placerat et, consectetur semper neque. In accumsan purus eu metus consectetur euismod at nec lacus. Nam purus leo, placerat eu ullamcorper eu, congue nec purus. Proin nibh odio, dignissim quis lobortis ac, luctus ut nisl. Fusce condimentum, odio id vulputate tincidunt, libero nisl mollis mi, sed hendrerit nisi odio ut eros. Morbi elementum venenatis justo eget aliquet. Suspendisse lorem tortor, placerat in ullamcorper dictum, consequat vitae lacus. Etiam molestie, massa ac placerat pellentesque, urna nisl condimentum massa, quis pellentesque ligula sem quis elit. Nam ullamcorper gravida elit, ac posuere massa volutpat eget. Duis tempus adipiscing quam, feugiat ultrices enim mollis sed. Sed at magna metus, eget porttitor orci. Vestibulum orci velit, luctus nec facilisis sed, imperdiet vel nunc. Nunc vulputate suscipit ullamcorper. Nam porta, nunc blandit mollis tristique, quam quam egestas metus, eget suscipit odio mi eu orci. Sed eu magna quis sapien venenatis ultricies.

    Cras facilisis bibendum enim ac feugiat. Nulla consectetur tellus at odio vehicula quis tincidunt massa imperdiet. Donec feugiat, mauris eu accumsan aliquet, sapien massa dapibus est, nec condimentum mi ipsum at felis. Etiam et tristique ipsum. Nulla facilisi. Etiam porttitor euismod nisl ac consequat. Pellentesque habitant morbi tristique senectus et netus et malesuada fames ac turpis egestas. Ut volutpat laoreet dolor, varius placerat lacus mollis eget. Ut mauris mi, pharetra vel fringilla a, elementum ut enim. Nulla urna mi, egestas tincidunt aliquet nec, commodo eget lacus.

  4. avatar
    Mauris felis sem, tincidunt ut. says:

    Duis quis quam elit, at facilisis mi. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Donec condimentum vestibulum mauris quis lacinia. Pellentesque vehicula faucibus erat cursus pharetra. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Aliquam tincidunt aliquam lectus, eget pretium leo facilisis et. Integer sodales, augue eget ornare viverra, leo diam accumsan massa, ac laoreet purus neque elementum mi. Nam suscipit ullamcorper dolor, et ornare purus egestas a. Nullam sit amet arcu dolor. Aenean et dui vitae lorem pharetra lacinia. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.

    Nunc sit amet augue vitae ligula tempor sodales non sed lorem. Maecenas varius lorem non leo ornare pulvinar. Sed mollis ligula ac sapien pharetra vitae fringilla mauris facilisis. Proin pellentesque hendrerit sem vitae dignissim. Phasellus aliquet condimentum tortor, in pellentesque elit cursus ut. Duis tortor metus, bibendum eget posuere non, commodo at elit. Cras pharetra dignissim orci in mollis. Suspendisse vulputate risus vel velit ornare fringilla. Sed placerat porta nisl in congue. Nam at nisi libero, nec suscipit justo. Curabitur nec lorem est, in accumsan massa.

  5. avatar
    Sed sit amet purus vel. says:

    Pellentesque tempor varius venenatis. Pellentesque pellentesque mollis auctor. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nulla facilisis risus ac quam laoreet posuere. Mauris vel diam eget eros ornare dapibus. In vestibulum nisi ut enim porttitor commodo sit amet a tortor. Nullam sed luctus quam. Morbi eget tempor mi. Sed tristique lectus id diam tincidunt quis ultricies velit cursus. Suspendisse potenti. Donec nec sem sapien. Duis luctus magna nec elit scelerisque elementum. Mauris nec eros id felis fringilla scelerisque.

    Nulla a quam et arcu ornare faucibus. Phasellus vitae tellus lorem. Nulla vehicula vestibulum eros id ultricies. Duis pellentesque nunc at nunc bibendum suscipit. Etiam ac diam ligula. Morbi faucibus felis eros. Nulla elit quam, scelerisque vel tempor molestie, adipiscing nec nisl. Fusce volutpat mi at ipsum consequat fermentum.

    Aliquam neque elit, ultricies vel condimentum quis, interdum a tortor. Pellentesque non orci dui. Sed odio augue, sodales at dignissim non, interdum a felis. Proin et lectus sem, eu facilisis eros. Sed consectetur tellus nec felis faucibus auctor. Morbi lorem turpis, vulputate a interdum nec, gravida ut leo. Aenean vestibulum leo facilisis augue scelerisque vulputate. Aenean ut interdum nunc. Nulla facilisi.

    Suspendisse in laoreet nibh. Mauris velit dui, tincidunt ut volutpat sit amet, tincidunt vel quam. Aenean risus felis, consequat a sollicitudin non, sagittis aliquam nibh. Donec lobortis accumsan condimentum. Praesent urna sapien, luctus in scelerisque et, imperdiet sed lacus. Curabitur sed leo mi, eget dapibus metus. Donec vitae dictum justo. Aliquam eu adipiscing quam. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Nullam nisi massa, venenatis ut fringilla vitae, condimentum eget purus. Phasellus a tellus a tortor lobortis eleifend eget id arcu. Sed ac erat turpis, et pulvinar nisl. Duis felis dui, ultricies sed blandit sit amet, viverra sit amet felis. Sed eu urna in magna posuere ultricies id et tellus.

    Nullam nec nulla dolor, quis fringilla tortor. Proin erat nibh, aliquet sed tristique vitae, ornare eget urna. Nam laoreet suscipit ultricies. Nam pellentesque posuere accumsan. Nullam tellus dui, bibendum vel ornare ullamcorper, ornare a erat. Cras dictum nibh id erat facilisis eu pretium est tincidunt. Phasellus condimentum ipsum in lorem vestibulum commodo. Mauris feugiat, ipsum a venenatis egestas, mi neque convallis diam, vitae rhoncus mauris dui sit amet nulla. Praesent accumsan enim nec enim blandit viverra semper urna malesuada. Sed condimentum, neque suscipit rutrum vehicula, est dui aliquam sapien, eget auctor urna augue id libero. Sed quis libero erat. Aenean non risus est.

Comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.